3 Assignments
Jessica Kahlow
Written assignments are a staple of educational assessment, providing a means for students to demonstrate their understanding, critical thinking, and communication skills. This chapter delves into various types of written assignments and offers guidance on how to design them effectively to enhance student learning and engagement.
The Importance of Written Assignments
Written assignments serve multiple educational purposes:
- Demonstrating Understanding: They allow students to articulate their comprehension of the material.
- Developing Critical Thinking: Written tasks encourage students to analyze, synthesize, and evaluate information.
- Enhancing Communication Skills: Writing assignments improve students’ ability to express ideas clearly and coherently.
Types of Written Assignments
1. Essays
Essays are a common type of written assignment that require students to explore a topic in depth, develop an argument, and support it with evidence.
- Types of Essays
-
- Expository Essays: Explain or describe a concept or idea.
- Persuasive Essays: Argue a specific point of view.
- Analytical Essays: Analyze a text, event, or idea.
- Narrative Essays: Tell a story or recount an event.
- Components of a Good Essay
-
- Clear Thesis Statement: The central argument or point of the essay.
- Structured Organization: Introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion.
- Evidence and Examples: Support the thesis with relevant information and analysis.
- Coherent Flow: Logical progression of ideas and smooth transitions.
2. Research Papers
Research papers require students to investigate a topic, gather information from various sources, and present their findings in a structured format.
- Components of a Good Research Paper
- Clear Research Question or Hypothesis: Defines the focus of the paper.
- Literature Review: Summarizes existing research on the topic.
- Methodology: Describes the research methods used to gather data.
- Analysis and Results: Presents the findings of the research.
- Discussion and Conclusion: Interprets the results and suggests implications or future research directions.
3. Reflective Journals
Reflective journals encourage students to reflect on their learning experiences, integrating personal insights with course content.
- Components of a Good Reflective Journal
- Personal Reflection: Discusses personal experiences and insights.
- Connection to Course Material: Links reflections to concepts and theories from the course.
- Critical Analysis: Examines experiences critically, considering different perspectives.
- Future Implications: Reflects on how the experience will influence future learning or actions.
4. Case Studies
Case studies involve detailed analysis of a real-world situation, requiring students to apply theoretical knowledge to practical scenarios.
- Components of a Good Case Study
- Clear Description of the Case: Provides background information and context.
- Identification of Key Issues: Highlights the main problems or challenges.
- Application of Theories and Concepts: Uses course material to analyze the case.
- Recommendations: Suggests practical solutions or actions based on the analysis.
5. Annotated Bibliographies
Annotated bibliographies require students to summarize and evaluate sources related to a specific topic.
- Components of a Good Annotated Bibliography
- Accurate Citations: Provides complete and correct bibliographic information.
- Summaries: Briefly describes the content of each source.
- Evaluations: Critically assesses the relevance, quality, and credibility of each source.
- Reflection: Discusses how each source contributes to the understanding of the topic.
Steps to Crafting Effective Written Assignments
Step 1: Define the Purpose and Objectives
Clearly articulate what you want students to achieve through the assignment. Consider the following:
- Learning Objectives: What skills or knowledge should students demonstrate?
- Purpose: Is the assignment intended to assess understanding, promote critical thinking, or encourage reflection?
Step 2: Choose the Appropriate Type of Assignment
Select a type of written assignment that aligns with your objectives and is suitable for the course content and student level.
Step 3: Develop Clear Instructions
Provide detailed instructions that outline:
- Assignment Goals: What students are expected to achieve.
- Format and Structure: Guidelines on length, formatting, and organization.
- Assessment Criteria: Rubrics or criteria that will be used to evaluate the assignment.
Step 4: Provide Resources and Support
Offer resources and support to help students succeed:
- Guidelines and Examples: Provide examples of good assignments and tips for effective writing.
- Research Resources: Recommend databases, journals, and other resources.
- Writing Support: Offer access to writing centers or online tools.
Step 5: Encourage Drafts and Revisions
Encourage students to submit drafts and provide feedback to help them improve their work before the final submission.
Step 6: Assess and Provide Feedback
Evaluate the assignments based on the established criteria and provide constructive feedback to guide further learning.
Best Practices for Written Assignments
You were up all night thinking about the perfect assignment. You started your morning off by typing up your thoughts and posting it to students as an assignment. And then… the emails come… “How long does it have to be?”, “Can I use a PowerPoint or do I have to do a video?”, “Why do I have to use this citation style?”, and “What do you mean by…”. Yikes! This was supposed to be the perfect assignment!
- Clarity and Precision: Ensure instructions and expectations are clear and precise.
- Alignment with Objectives: Make sure the assignment aligns with the learning objectives of the course.
- Engagement and Relevance: Design assignments that are engaging and relevant to students’ interests and experiences.
- Feedback and Support: Provide timely and constructive feedback, and offer support throughout the process.
Writing Assignment Directions
Maybe it’s still the perfect assignment, but your prompt didn’t give students enough information. Try to predict the questions students will ask and make sure your prompt addresses those by including these five components:
1. Introduction
This situates the assignment within the context of the course, reminding students of what they have been working on in anticipation of the assignment and how that work has prepared them to succeed at it.
2. Justification, Purpose, and Summary
In a few sentences explain the overall assignment mission and type of assignment.
Explain why the particular type of assignment you’ve chosen (e.g., lab report, policy memo, problem set, or personal reflection) is the best way for you and your students to measure how well they’ve met the learning objectives associated with this segment of the course.
3. Detailed Tasks/Key Components
Outline what students are supposed to do at a granular level. Is there a step-by-step process they need to follow? What are the key components they need to make sure to include?
4. Logistics/Submission Format
Explain how and when students will submit. Include items like:
- Due date
- Requirements for length, formatting/styling, document type, and citation style
- Location and type of submission
5. Evaluation Criteria
Outline the criteria you will use to evaluate students work. This could be in a detailed list or rubric.
It is helpful to explain what criteria look like at certain performance levels. For example, what does “A” work look like, “B” work look like? Or what comprises “Meets expectations” vs. “Does not meet expectations”?
Writing Student Presentation Directions
Group or individual presentations can be an essential part of student participation because it “fosters interaction among students”, especially when they’re also asked to share comments and questions about others’ presentations (Ko & Rossen, 2017, p. 329). Moreover, online presentations are a great way for students to share their work with their classmates. Online presentations afford students more tools to convey their ideas.
Having students give presentations is easy enough in a face-to-face class – everyone is present and there aren’t many technology considerations that have to be made. But in an online format, a once-simple assignment gets more complex.
- How can students record presentations that include sharing a screen, video of themselves, and audio?
- How can students submit their videos so that just the professor can watch them?
- How can they submit videos so that their peers can view and comment?
We’re going to walk through all the options so you can choose what is right for your course, and then we’ll also provide resources for you to pass along to your students for whichever method you choose.
Presentation Options
There are two main choices you have to make.
- Assignment type: Will it be an individual or a group presentation?
- Audience: Will students submit it just to the professor or will their classmates also be able to see it?
If the audience is only the instructor, you may want your students to do a presentation or video recording that does not need to be viewed by the entire class. For this, you’ll use a Canvas online submission assignment, and students will embed their video into their submission.
If the audience is the classmates and the instructor, create a discussion in Canvas. Students can embed their videos into discussion posts. You can set up groups in those discussions so that only those in the groups can see the presentations, or you can leave them open to the whole class.
Tools and Technologies for Supporting Written Assignments
Learning Management Systems (LMS)
Platforms like Moodle, Canvas, and Blackboard facilitate the submission, grading, and feedback processes for written assignments.
Writing Tools
Tools like Grammarly, Turnitin, and the Purdue OWL offer writing assistance and plagiarism checking.
Collaboration Tools
Google Docs, Microsoft Teams, and other collaboration tools enable peer review and collaborative writing projects.
Crafting effective written assignments requires thoughtful planning, clear communication, and ongoing support. By understanding the various types of written assignments and following best practices for their design and implementation, educators can create meaningful assessments that enhance student learning and engagement. Written assignments not only evaluate students’ understanding and skills but also foster critical thinking, creativity, and effective communication.
Preventing Plagiarized Assignments and Promoting Academic Integrity
Plagiarism remains a significant challenge in academic settings, undermining the integrity of educational institutions and devaluing the hard work of honest students. As educators, it is our responsibility to create an environment that promotes academic integrity and deters dishonest practices. This chapter explores effective strategies for preventing plagiarism, including the use of TurnItIn and designing plagiarism-proof assignments.
Promoting Academic Integrity
Academic integrity is the cornerstone of a credible educational system. It ensures that students are evaluated based on their own work and merit. Promoting this integrity involves not only setting clear expectations but also creating a culture where honesty is valued and celebrated. Here are key steps to fostering an environment of academic integrity:
- Clearly Communicate Expectations: Educate students about what constitutes plagiarism and the consequences of engaging in it. Provide clear guidelines on citation practices and the importance of original work.
- Foster a Culture of Trust and Respect: Encourage open communication and build trust with your students. When students feel respected and supported, they are less likely to resort to dishonest practices.
- Provide Resources and Support: Offer resources such as writing centers, citation guides, and workshops on academic integrity. Support students in developing their research and writing skills.
Use of TurnItIn
TurnItIn is a widely used tool that helps detect and prevent plagiarism by comparing student submissions against a vast database of academic work, websites, and other sources. Here’s how TurnItIn can be effectively utilized:
- Submission and Originality Reports: Require students to submit their assignments through TurnItIn. Review the originality reports generated to identify potential instances of plagiarism.
- Educate Students on TurnItIn: Explain to students how TurnItIn works and how it can benefit them by highlighting areas that need proper citation. This transparency can encourage students to engage more deeply with their own work.
- Use TurnItIn as a Learning Tool: Rather than solely a policing mechanism, use TurnItIn to educate students about proper citation and the importance of academic integrity. Provide feedback on how they can improve their writing and avoid unintentional plagiarism.
Designing Plagiarism-Proof Assignments
Designing assignments that are challenging to plagiarize is a proactive way to prevent academic dishonesty. Plagiarism-proofing assignments involves making them more specific, personal, and process-oriented. Below are strategies for creating such assignments:
- Use Unique and Specific Prompts: Tailor prompts to the course material and student interests. This specificity makes it difficult for students to find pre-written answers online.
- Personalize Projects: Encourage students to connect assignments to their personal experiences or future career goals. Personal reflections are inherently unique and harder to plagiarize.
- Incorporate Current Events: Use recent developments in the field to keep topics fresh and less likely to be found in existing sources.
- Focus on the Creation Process: Require multiple drafts and check-ins for larger papers and projects. This ongoing engagement makes it harder for students to submit plagiarized work.
- Include Reflective Essays: Ask students to explain their work and decision-making process. Reflective essays help verify the authenticity of their submissions.
- Test Your Prompts: Search the assignment directions online or use an AI tool like ChatGPT to generate responses. This can help you gauge how easily your prompts can be plagiarized and adjust accordingly.
Example: Plagiarism-Proof Assignments
Not Plagiarism-Proof
Essay Prompt: The Evolution of Modern Architecture
Instructions: Write a 1,000-1,200 word essay discussing the evolution of modern architecture. Consider the following points: Key characteristics of modern architecture, influential architects, technological advancements, and changes in urban landscapes.
Why It’s Not Plagiarism-Proof: This prompt is generic and easily searchable, with many pre-written essays available online.
Plagiarism-Proof Version
Personal Exploration of Modern Architecture’s Evolution
Instructions: Write a 1,000-1,200 word essay exploring the evolution of modern architecture through a personalized lens. Incorporate the following elements:
Local Case Study: Select a modern building or project in your city. Describe its key characteristics and how it exemplifies modern architectural principles.
Architect Interview: Conduct a brief interview with a local architect or architecture professor to gain insights. Include quotes and reflections from the interview.
Personal Experience: Reflect on a modern architectural space you have visited. Discuss how the design impacted your experience and understanding of modern architecture.
Technological Influence: Analyze how technological advancements influenced the building in your local case study.
Additional Requirements:
Original Photos or Sketches: Include photographs or sketches of the building.
Process Documentation: Document your research process, including selecting your case study, conducting your interview, and gathering reflections.
Why It’s Plagiarism-Proof: This prompt requires original research, personal reflection, and locally-sourced material, making it difficult to plagiarize.
Preventing plagiarism and promoting academic integrity are critical aspects of fostering a trustworthy and effective educational environment. By utilizing tools like TurnItIn and designing plagiarism-proof assignments, educators can create a learning atmosphere where honesty is paramount and students are encouraged to produce original, thoughtful work. Embracing these strategies ensures that academic achievements genuinely reflect students’ knowledge and efforts, ultimately enriching the educational experience for all.
References
Wick, A. (2020). 4 Tips for writing good online assignment directions. Cengage. https://todayslearner.cengage.com/writing-good-online-assignment-instructions/
BOK Center, Harvard University (n.d.). How to Write an Effective Assignment. https://bokcenter.harvard.edu/how-to-write-assignment-prompt
Southwestern University (n.d.). Six Parts of an Effective Prompt. https://www.southwestern.edu/offices/writing/faculty-resources-for-writing-instruction/effective-writing-assignments/six-parts-of-an-effective-prompt/.